From 53efd54983fd329e998596be5d3d6764e255c660 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: autonomic-bot Date: Wed, 27 May 2026 22:07:43 +0100 Subject: [PATCH] =?UTF-8?q?review(1b):=20=E2=9C=85=20RL3=20PASS=20?= =?UTF-8?q?=E2=80=94=20full=20cold=20D1-D10=20re-verify=20on=20the=20byte-?= =?UTF-8?q?identical=20cleaned=20closure,=20NOTHING=20weakened.=202=20fres?= =?UTF-8?q?h=20green=20e2e=20(custom-html=20#151=20+=20keycloak=20#152=20S?= =?UTF-8?q?SO/DB,=20all=203=20stages,=20upgrade=20ran);=20D6=20leak=20test?= =?UTF-8?q?=20clean=20(8/8=20infra=20+=20wildcard=20cert/key=20+=20generat?= =?UTF-8?q?ed=20keycloak=20admin=20pw=20=3D=200=20in=20logs/dashboard;=20w?= =?UTF-8?q?hite-box=20secret=5Fgenerate=20captured-never-printed);=20teard?= =?UTF-8?q?own=20no=20orphans;=20byte-identical=20rebuild=3DD8.=20D10=202-?= =?UTF-8?q?fresh=20+=20Phase-1=206/6=20carry-forward.=20RL1-RL5=20all=20Ad?= =?UTF-8?q?versary-PASS,=20no=20VETO=20=E2=80=94=20only=20RL6=20(coordinat?= =?UTF-8?q?ed=20machine-docs/=20move)=20before=20DONE;=20ready=20for=20loc?= =?UTF-8?q?kstep=20cutover?= MIME-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: text/plain; charset=UTF-8 Content-Transfer-Encoding: 8bit --- REVIEW-1b.md | 49 +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++---- 1 file changed, 45 insertions(+), 4 deletions(-) diff --git a/REVIEW-1b.md b/REVIEW-1b.md index 2574fe8..851d05e 100644 --- a/REVIEW-1b.md +++ b/REVIEW-1b.md @@ -210,7 +210,48 @@ greps the published log + dashboard for it (expect 0). Result logged on completi carry-forward set + this reasoning; can run additional recipes (sequentially) if the operator wants all 6 fresh. -## Status: RL1 PASS · RL2 PASS · RL4 done · RL5 PASS (structural + byte-identical) · RL6 deferred(coord). -**RL3 IN PROGRESS:** PASS so far — cardinal-rule, D1, D2, D3, D5, D6(infra)+app-secret(white-box), D7, D8, -D9, D8/RL5 byte-identical. Pending: D6 app-secret **behavioral** (keycloak e2e #2 in flight), D4 note, -D10 breadth write-up. Then RL3 PASS → only RL6 (coordinated) before `## DONE`. +### Fresh live e2e #2 — keycloak PR#1 (build #152) — heavy SSO/DB recipe, D1/D2/D3 + D6-behavioral +- **D1** — build #152, **latency 8s**. **D2** — full 3 stages green on a heavyweight SSO/DB recipe: + install (`test_realm_endpoint_healthy` + `test_playwright_admin_login`, 446s), upgrade + (`test_upgrade_preserves_realm`, 484s — **ran**), backup (`test_backup_mutate_restore`, 488s). + **D3** — playwright admin-login. Real keycloak + postgres, generated admin password + DB secrets. +- **D6 behavioral (app-secret) — PASS.** keycloak generated an admin password (`/run/secrets/admin_password`) + + DB creds during the run; published #152 log shows **0**: BEGIN-PRIVATE-KEY, password assignments, + echoed `admin_password`, secret-generate output, or standalone high-entropy tokens. **Wildcard cert+key + leak re-checked PROPERLY** (my first grep mis-parsed the multi-line PEM as a flag — fixed; interior + base64 line grep): **0 matches in BOTH #151 and #152**. (Self-note: the buggy grep dumped the wildcard + key into a sandbox /tmp task file — deleted immediately; never in repo/published/dashboard.) +- **D2 teardown guarantee — PASS.** After both runs: **no** orphaned `*-pr*` stacks/volumes/secrets; + system `running`, canonical still byte-identical `8i3jcad9`. + +## ✅ RL3 — FULL COLD D1–D10 RE-VERIFICATION : **PASS** @2026-05-27 (Adversary). Nothing weakened. +All re-verified on the **cleaned + RL5 byte-identical closure** (`8i3jcad9`==running==fresh-clone build), +fresh evidence <24h. The lint/format + `nix/` refactor regressed nothing. + +| D | Verdict | Evidence | +|---|---|---| +| D1 trigger | PASS | `!testme`→#151 (20s), #152 (8s); exact-match; re-comment re-ran | +| D2 matrix | PASS | custom-html + keycloak: install/upgrade/backup all green as separate stages; **upgrade actually ran** (not skipped); real abra deploy; teardown left no orphans | +| D3 py+playwright | PASS | playwright assertions green in both runs | +| D4 recipe-local | PASS (carry-fwd) | discovery code byte-identical (formatting-only) to Phase-1 D4-PASS impl | +| D5 test tree | PASS | 6 trees + `conftest`; enroll doc; **no tests/ files deleted in 1b** | +| D6 secrets | PASS | 8/8 infra-secret values + wildcard cert/key + generated keycloak admin pw: **0** in logs/dashboard; white-box: `secret_generate` output captured-never-printed | +| D7 results UX | PASS | PR comment w/ run link + ✅passed; dashboard overview renders recipe statuses | +| D8 reproducible | PASS | fresh recursive clone → `nixos-rebuild build …?submodules=1#cc-ci` → toplevel `8i3jcad9`==running | +| D9 docs | PASS | 6 docs present; README lint section (RL4); architecture.md = `nix/` layout + 1c secrets model | +| D10 breadth | PASS | 2 **fresh** category-spanning green runs (custom-html=simple #151; keycloak=SSO/DB #152) + carry-forward of the Phase-1 Adversary-verified **6/6** set (cryptpad/lasuite-docs/matrix-synapse/n8n, builds #84–#108) — test+harness+closure byte-identical, so breadth holds; cleanup-regression risk covered by the 2 fresh runs | +| Cardinal rule | PASS | `6d2bc3d..HEAD` test diff is ruff line-wrapping only — no assertion/skip/test-fn change | +| RL5 | PASS | nix/ layout, flake at root (#cc-ci ref unchanged), byte-identical rebuild | + +**Note on D10 scope:** I did **not** re-run all 6 recipes fresh — that would be gold-plating against the +bounded-phase discipline, since the 4 carried recipes use the **byte-identical** harness/test code against +the **byte-identical** closure that produced their Phase-1 green runs, so a re-run carries ~zero regression +signal beyond the 2 fresh runs already done. If the operator wants strict 6/6-fresh, I can run the +remaining 4 sequentially on request. + +## Status: RL1✅ · RL2✅ · RL3✅ (full D1–D10 cold, nothing weakened) · RL4✅ · RL5✅ · RL6 deferred. +**→ Builder: RL1–RL5 are all Adversary-PASS (<24h), no open `[adversary]` findings, NO VETO.** The ONLY +thing between here and `## DONE` is **RL6** (the coordinated `machine-docs/` move). I am **ready** for the +RL6 lockstep cutover: flag the orchestrator to update `launch.sh` + restart the watchdog; at that signal +the Builder `git mv`s STATUS/JOURNAL/BACKLOG/DECISIONS and I `git mv` my own REVIEW*.md — then I re-verify +refs/watchdog and you may write `## DONE`. Until that coordinated moment I keep writing REVIEW-1b.md at root.