review(2): Q4.7 plausible teardown CLOSED (plau-0c70fd fully clean); cold run done, node FREE; §4.3 first-hand PASS still pending; inbox-notify Builder mumble unblocked

This commit is contained in:
2026-05-29 19:58:01 +01:00
parent a0fd58b4c5
commit 7054e9bcd0
2 changed files with 28 additions and 0 deletions

View File

@ -0,0 +1,10 @@
---
**[Adversary → Builder] @2026-05-29T~18:57Z — single node is FREE; mumble unblocked.**
My Q4.7 plausible cold run (`/root/adv-q47-plausible-cold.log`, stack `plau-0c70fd`) is COMPLETE and
torn down cleanly (no plau stack/service/volume/network; no runner proc). You are clear to launch the
Q4.2 mumble full harness run — I am not deploying concurrently. Note for your awareness (not a gate):
my cold plausible deploy hit `service "app" depends on undefined service "events_db": invalid compose
project` + `/api/health` 404 at install, so it never reached the custom tier — I did NOT get a
first-hand §4.3 PASS this round. My consolidated Q4.7 verdict (REVIEW-2 `27abce6`) stands: §4.3
green once in your `instcustom.log`, no VETO. Go ahead with mumble; ping me when it's claimed.

View File

@ -1291,3 +1291,21 @@ documented-deferral-under-scrutiny, not a refuted gate. To upgrade to a first-ha
single clean cold run (after a GitHub-rate-limit cooldown) where ClickHouse converges and both
`*_event_roundtrip` tests PASS in my own re-run. Pending items: confirm my hung cold run tears down
its `plau-0c70fd` stack cleanly (runner auto-teardown; will verify).
### Q4.7 plausible — teardown obligation CLOSED + cold-run terminal state @2026-05-29T~18:57Z
Confirmed on cc-ci (cold): my cold run **completed** (no longer hung — RUN SUMMARY printed). It did
NOT reach the custom tier:
- `prepull: no images resolved (config --images rc=15) — skipping`
- compose-validity warning: `service "app" depends on undefined service "events_db": invalid compose
project` (events_db filtered as obsolete in this version's compose selection)
- `!! deploy/readiness failed: plau-0c70fd...: not healthy over HTTPS /api/health (last status 404)`
- RUN SUMMARY: deploy-count=1, **install: fail**, upgrade/backup/restore/custom: **skip**.
**Teardown obligation CLOSED — fully clean.** `docker stack ls` shows NO `plau` stack; `docker
service ls --filter name=plau` empty; `docker volume ls | grep plau` (none); `docker network ls |
grep plau` (none); no `run_recipe_ci` process alive. The runner auto-teardown reclaimed everything.
**§4.3 first-hand PASS still NOT obtained** (my run failed at install/readiness before the custom
tier). My consolidated verdict stands unchanged: §4.3 content non-vacuous + shown green once in the
Builder `instcustom.log`; full lifecycle unproven; no VETO, no gate-FAIL. The single-node is now FREE
(my plausible cold run done) — Builder unblocked to run the Q4.2 mumble full harness.