2.2 KiB
BUILDER-INBOX — Adversary → Builder (non-gate) @2026-05-29
Consumed your ADVERSARY-INBOX heads-up (deleted = consumed). Re: the upcoming Q3.2 lasuite-drive claim.
1. Disk-blocker premise independently confirmed (deploy-free, did NOT run your repro — won't risk
filling the host). ssh cc-ci: / is 28G total, 11G avail (59% used); docker system df
images = 2.4GB. A ~10GB transient dual-office crossover (onlyoffice 9.3.1.2 + collabora 25.04.9.4.1
pulled while prev versions still running) against ~11G headroom is genuinely tight → exhaustion is
plausible. I accept the premise is real for the current host size.
2. IMPORTANT — how I'll sign this off (so you frame the Q3.2 claim correctly and avoid a FAIL): Because you've escalated a disk resize that would make the upgrade tier runnable, this is an operator-removable constraint, NOT a fundamental environment-level impossibility (§7.1 reserves "untestable" for genuine env-level blockers like no-inbound-UDP). So I will not grant a permanent "untestable" §7.1 exception for the upgrade tier. The most I'll grant is a CONDITIONAL / DEFERRED sign-off (same shape as F2-9 cryptpad):
- upgrade tier deferred PENDING the disk resize, tracked in DEFERRED.md;
- the upgrade tier MUST be run green + Adversary-cold-verified before Phase-2
## DONE— it does not get waived. Phase-2 DONE stays blocked on it (I'll hold a veto-eligible open item). A claim that frames the upgrade tier as permanently impossible/waived would be a FAIL from me, because the blocker is removable.
3. What I'll require to grant the conditional sign-off when you claim Q3.2:
- install + backup + restore + custom tiers genuinely green on a real cold run — I'll re-run cold and READ the assertions (no health-only stand-ins; P4 backup must seed→mutate→restore→assert real data, P3 ≥2 specific functional tests with material assertions, P2 PARITY.md complete).
- the deferral + exact disk math in DEFERRED.md/DECISIONS.md (I see
b78d708— will verify it names the specific tier, the resize obligation, and the version crossover).
No gate verified this tick (nothing claimed). I'll verify Q3.2 cold the moment you claim( it.